Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: OLIVIA JANIE WARD


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 7
Date:
In the coverup of the murder of Olivia Jane Ward j


JANIE'S DEATH has now been ruled a homicide murder after 15 long years of her parents trying to get law enforcement authorities to act, a court order finally allowed a second" real autopsy to be performed"

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:
Olivia Jane Ward


Have you heard about the 16 year old unsolved death of a then 16 year old girl Olivia Jane Ward ? She was fondly known as Janie by those that love and misss her.


Her death occured September 9th, 1989 in Marshall Arkansas, in Searcy County, population 7,841.


A major cover-up began that night and has continued since that time.



__________________
Miz G


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 381
Date:

Feel free to put her story out here , Welcome aboard.


                                                                                God Bless,


                                                                                     itsybitsy



__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Thank you for the welcome. This is my first time on a board like this. So, bear with me.


I will share the information with you.


Miz G



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

This is for starters -
 
Janie Ward, 16 years old, was pronounced dead on September 9, 1989. The circumstances surrounding her death have left many questions. The official story given by law enforcement would like for us to believe she simply "fell off a 9 3/4 inch high porch", and died.

In October 2004, after 15 years of fighting for an exhumation, a new autopsy was performed by Harry Bonnell. Dr. Bonnell found that not only was Janie's spinal cord separated by an extremely forceful blow, but there had been obvious internal bleeding in her neck, left shoulder, cheek and forehead, as well as a black eye and a disclored broken nose...none of which had been noted in the original autopsy report, done by Dr. Fahmy Malak. Bonnell said it was obvious to him, that Janie's death was a "Homicide", caused by blunt force impact and trauma to the face, and that there was no way she could have died in the manner some witnesses described. "It took enormous force to break her neck and injure her head in this way", he said.

The State is opposing the request by the Family and their Attorney, to change the death certificate to homicide.

 
 

__________________
Miz G


Pre-Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:

Hi, Miz G No I have never heard of this unsolved death. Welcome!


QCL



__________________
QCL


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

QUEENCITYLADY wrote:



Hi, Miz G No I have never heard of this unsolved death. Welcome! QCL



Sorry I  have not been posting. I will begin by posting some columns written by Mike Masterson, a Staff columnist for the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. I will begin with the most recent one.


Mike having been in contact with the Parents of Olivia Jane Ward has written many columns since late October 2004. He has read many of the documents and interviewed various persons that may have first hand knowledge concerning "Janies" brutal death, September 9, 1989.


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette; Date:Tuesday, OCT 04, 2005

And the beat(ing) goes on

Mike Masterson

  The state of Arkansas continues to frustrate and beat back a Marshall couple’s efforts to find truth and justice in the 1989 death of their 16-yearold daughter, Janie.
   State officials’ responses to interrogatories (formal questions) in Ron and Mona Ward’s ongoing legal attempt to have the manner of Janie’s demise reclassified from "undetermined" to "homicide " on the death certificate are incomplete.
   That’s my conclusion based on my examination of the responses submitted by the state Crime Laboratory and the medical examiner’s office to questions submitted by the Wards’ attorney.
   Such stonewalling, though inexcusable, is nothing new. The state, through law enforcement, prosecutors, the Crime Lab and the medical examiner’s office, has gone well beyond reason to keep both the manner and cause of Janie’s death lingering as undetermined. This despite an exhumation and re-autopsy almost one year ago in which Dr. Harry Bonnell, a board-certified California forensic pathologist, opined that Janie’s death was a homicide caused by trauma that fractured both her neck and nose.
   The original pathologist, Arkansas’ former chief medical examiner, Dr. Fahmy Malak, failed to note the fatal fracture in his autopsy. Nor did he even describe her hands, which had been covered in plastic bags to preserve evidence. In photographs, the hands appear to be injured and filthy. Malak ruled that the cause of Janie’s death was an upper spinal cord and neck "injury," but he found that the manner of death was undetermined and said it required further investigation.
   Bonnell provided many more crucial details. But rather than accepting his non-politicized findings and thanking him for finally clearing up this long unresolved case, the current chief medical examiner, Dr. Charles Kokes, and officials with the Crime Lab have chosen to resist all efforts to amend Janie’s death certificate.
   In 1992, out-of-state pathologists Marc Krouse and Michael Graham were paid by the Crime Lab to review Janie’s case and a number of others. The board accepted their recommendation that the cause of Janie’s death be changed to "undetermined," and a chancery judge ordered the change in April 1993.
   Both of those doctors, along with Kokes, are listed by the state as potential witnesses in the state’s fight to discredit Bonnell and keep Janie’s death classified as undetermined. In short, this poor family from the Ozarks remains pitted against the financial and political clout of our entire state government.
   The problem the state faces, however, is how to use the 13-year-old findings of a couple of consulting pathologists who have never even seen Janie’s body to try and discredit one of only two forensic pathologists to actually perform an autopsy on her remains.
   Any such attempts to shoot down Bonnell’s credibility would have to be based solely on reviews of an X-ray photo that blanked out Janie’s fractured neck altogether and the woefully incomplete investigative and initial autopsy records. Let’s hope the Wards have a judge who can see, hear and smell that there is something very foul in this matter.
   To make this ludicrous situation even worse, when Bonnell came to Arkansas last October, Kokes, the current medical examiner, and the Crime Lab refused to allow him to use their facilities for the second autopsy. Why wouldn’t they have welcomed him and his attempts to resolve this case? You know the answer to that as well as I do by now.
   In fact, Kokes did not even provide a staff member to observe and assist Bonnell.
   The state, at every level, continues to hide from this disgraceful case as the Ward family suffers in every way imaginable as a result of all this shucking and dodging.
   Here is an example from one response to those interrogatories I mentioned above. The Wards’ attorney, Jerry Sallings of Little Rock, asked what the Crime Lab knew about the wet sheet that was mentioned in an investigator’s statement.
   Surely the lab knows about this sheet. I’m sitting here looking at two Crime Lab reports dated Sept. 10 and 12, 1989, that both describe the wet sheet as having been taken into custody for trace evidence analysis. The recipient is listed as Steve Dillon, the lab’s chief field investigator. No one I know has ever seen a form describing the results of that analysis.
   The state’s official response to the question about this sheet? "Respondents have no knowledge or information" concerning this question. So what are these official documents that I’m looking at right now? I can get them and the respondents can’t?
   According to Ron Ward, the special prosecutor in Janie’s case, Tim Williamson of Mena, continues to ignore the Wards’ daily e-mail requests for any updates and has failed to respond even to their attorney’s messages and inquiries. I can’t blame Ward for feeling as he does. As he recently expressed it in writing to a producer at ABC News, "Janie’s case is not just about a little country girl killed. . . . It goes much deeper and tugs at the very roots of our judicial system. . . . [A] cover-up of such magnitude warrants national attention."
   What if Janie had been your child?
   —–––––
•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.




-- Edited by Miz G at 20:56, 2005-10-11

__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

How would you feel if your Daughter's dead body appeared in the back of a pick-up truck September 9th, 1989 at the Sheriff's office ?
How would you feel if the elected and appointed officials failed to properly investigate that case ? 
How would you feel if that case was closed, yet was documented to be "undetermined ?"

Then 15 years later the Prosecuting Attorney (H.G. Foster) recuses himself from the case.
A Special Prosecuting Attorney (Tim Williamson) is assigned the case December 2004.
January 2005 he goes to a Church in the hometown of the Parents of the dead girl, holds hands with the Parents and prays for justice to prevail.
But, since July 21st 2005 that Special Prosecutor has failed to respond to the many e-mails from not only the Parents but their Attorney.
Ask yourself how you would feel ?
­Donations are being accepted for the Justice For Janie Fund.
 
First Team Bank
PO Box 398
Marshall AR 72650
 
Justice For Janie Fund Account #  93002194

The funds are to help defray the expenses the Ward Family have had, and continue to incur in their 16 year effort to find Justice For Janie.
Any help you can give would be appreciated. If there is no Justice for Janie, there is no Justice for anyone.
This family has not only suffered the loss of their precious Daughter, they have spent their life savings, and their legal bills continue to accrue.
Your prayers will be appreciated too.
 
 
 
 


__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Following is another article by Mike Masterson on Janie Ward. Mike published a letter from the Father of Olivia Jane Ward in this column.


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Thursday September 8th, 2005 Editiorial Section Page 19


A letter from a dad
Mike Masterson

It will be 16 years tomorrow afternoon that Olivia Jane Ward died from a broken neck while attending a junior class party outside her hometown of Marshall. Mysteriously, authorities have failed to gain either answers or justice for the 16-year-old girl and her family.
   The official manner of her death, supposedly from a backward topple of fewer than than 10 inches, has languished conveniently as "undetermined." It has never been ruled "accidental," as some news accounts have either mistakenly stated or implied.
   In fact, it appears to me that authorities at every level have gone out of their way, and continue to do so even today, to avoid prosecuting this case as the homicide from a frontal assault that a nationally regarded medical examiner found it to be in 2004.
   So as Ron and Mona Ward and their attorney patiently wait for Special Prosecutor Tim Williamson of Mena to respond to their unanswered e-mails and inquiries about his ongoing "investigation," I asked the father if he cared to pen a letter to his daughter on this anniversary of her death.
   Ron waited a few days, then sent the following, written on his birthday:
   "My dearest Janie:
   "I miss you so. Words just can’t describe the feelings of missing you and the heartache at times; it’s almost too much to bear. Why did you have to go to that stupid party? Here I am blaming you. Please forgive me.
   "I know you tried to be friends with everyone. I feel so guilty that I wasn’t there to defend you. Sometimes at night when I can’t sleep, I visit your grave, but, Janie, you know that. I wish you would come and visit with me again; the last time I saw your smiling face in the sky was just not long enough.
   "The day they buried you, I gave you my promise that I would do everything I possibly could to bring your killer to justice. I know I’ve not been the greatest father in seeing my vow kept, but you know how deeply I love you.
   "It will soon be 16 years since that promise, and I will not give up until justice is served. Janie, you are right. Your dad must do it the legal way or I will become the bad guy and can never be with you again.
   "Do you reckon you could get God to pay Tim Williamson a little visit to encourage and remind him of holding hands in prayer with your mom and me? Could you ask him to remember his promise to us, made in God’s own house, that he would investigate your death as a homicide, as it should have been investigated in the beginning, and bring your killer to justice?
   "All this waiting, this emotional roller coaster ride that we have been on all these years with no help from the officials, has taken its toll. Remember how Tim told us about the father of the little girl murdered down at Mena being so stressed out from her death and all that it weakened the man so badly and he died?
   "We are strong in our faith with the Lord; that and righteous anger keep us going, and there will be justice for you one day soon. Not by power or by might, but by his spirit. Can’t wait to see your smiling face again.
   "Love, Dad."
   Now I can’t speak for you, fellow Arkansas parents, grandparents and citizens, but I’m constantly amazed that this ordinary family, whose only transgression was loving their daughter, has persevered under such a staggeringly unacceptable, even openly hostile approach by our state’s criminal justice system.
   Any thoughts that you as readers, parents or concerned citizens might care to share with Williamson can be either e-mailed to prosecutor18 west @aol.com or snail-mailed to him at P.O. Drawer 109, Mena AR 71953-0109, or you can write a letter to the Voices page. I feel certain the Wards would be as thankful as you might be if you were living life in their shoes tomorrow.
—–––––
•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.






 





 



­­

 


 


 



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

This was published Tuesday July 19th and the Ward Family received their last e-mail from SP Tim Williamson Thursday July 21st. Mr. Williamson said he would be taking a much needed vacation with his family and would return Tuesday August 1st.
Ron Ward sent the first (of other) e-mail's to Mr. Williamson Wednesday August 2nd.
Their Attorney has also written e-mail's and sent letters through regular mail. Mr. Williamson has failed to respond to them too.
Most anyone can plainly see, that the Ward Family would feel justified in being upset, even more so when the 16th Anniversary of Janie's death is Friday September 9th.

A record of nonsense

Posted on Tuesday, July 19, 2005 Arkansas Democrat-Gazette



A lot of things just make no sense to Ron and Mona Ward of Marshall about the way authorities have so irrationally pursued the truth about their teen-age daughter’s 1989 death.


They don’t understand how public officials allowed so many flagrant contradictions by witnesses to slip by without deeper questioning or why some secondary witnesses were put under oath while others who claim to have seen Janie Ward’s fall were not.


In that vein, Ron Ward recently wrote to Special Prosecutor Tim Williamson of Mena to ask why the adult parolee whom police say purchased beer for the teen-agers at the party where his daughter died was never charged with contributing to the delinquency of minors.


Instead, Ward years ago found himself charged with terroristic threatening, a misdemeanor, when he tried to ask the parolee, Gary Don Snow, who was also one of the three professed witnesses to Janie’s fatal fall, about the details surrounding her death.


Below, in part, is what Ward recently sent to Williamson: "Tim: I have read Gary Snow’s statements. There lies an undertone that he does agree to be very cooperative in lieu of the fact that he could be charged and have his parole revoked if he changed his fall story.


" Tim, did you also not note [in the official record] that [Arkansas State Police] Investigator [Bill] Beach [during interrogation] encouraged Snow seven times to file harassment charges against me for asking/trying to ask him questions [about Janie’s death] and that Snow also brought people to my home and that he stated to Inv. Beach [that] nothing would have ever been said about Janie’s death if it had not been for me pushing the issue. "The whole fall story was built around a drunken fall, ‘AN ACCIDENT’ (and Tim, Janie’s death has never, never been ruled accidental). The fact remains [that] Snow supplied alcohol to a party where a teen-ager died and no charges were filed against him. The fact remains that the only charge ever filed against anyone in Janie’s case was against me, her father, by Gary Snow."


Here is Williamson’s response, also in part: "Good morning, Ron. You have asked a valid question. When I first read the file, I too was curious as to why no adults were charged with any ‘alcohol and minors’ violations. It is very common to file such charges. However, it is sometimes necessary to refrain from filing such in order to compel testimony or investigative cooperation.


" The file does not indicate [that] any cooperation agreement was made with any party in this case. I am looking forward to a new interview with this subject. "


In other words, valued readers, Gary Don Snow, an adult at the time who told police he was on parole for crimes committed in Oklahoma, was never charged with contributing to the delinquency of minors at a party where a young girl died under highly questionable circumstances.


Instead, on numerous occasions during their interview, the ASP investigator advises and reminds Snow that he can file harassment charges against Ward if he even attempts to ask Snow anything specific about Janie’s death.


What do you suppose was up with all that?


The dead girl’s father for years has sought to learn why Snow seemingly got such consideration from authorities who already had acquired the receipts for the two kegs of beer sold for that junior class party.


Yet Snow, along with professed eyewitnesses Sarah Patterson Pounders and Billy Don Harris, were the only three who said they saw Janie mysteriously fall backward off the porch, then lie there to die.


After reading the transcript of the interview between Beach and Snow, I’m also wondering why Snow was repeatedly encouraged to file harassment charges against the grieving father, which he ended up doing after Ward tried to speak with him about Janie’s death. Amazingly, that case was later dismissed after Snow failed to appear.


Ward, who has become increasingly frustrated after not hearing of a single witness being interviewed after six months of Williamson’s renewed" investigation" into Janie’s death, said he already would have sworn and interviewed a number of the witnesses who initially gave unsworn statements to the Searcy County sheriff and the state police investigator.


For instance, Ward said that months ago he would have interviewed partygoer Christopher Loggins, a nephew of the current sheriff who stated in part that Janie came out of the house and walked past him, then he heard a noise that sounded as if she had run into something. Loggins also stated that he turned to see her lying on the ground. He said he, Sarah Patterson (now Pounders), Jeanie Cannada (now Mathis) and Tony Horton all had gone to the party together.


But in Beach’s notes, where Loggins and Horton say they left the party, there was no mention of Patterson or Cannada having departed with them. Although he gave a statement, Loggins has yet to be put under oath in the case. Beach did use him as a purported witness to Janie’s alleged fall on a "re-enactment" video made at the scene.


Ward said he also believes that Horton, who also has never been sworn to tell the truth, is another previously interviewed witness whose testimony under oath might help get to the truth. In his statement, Horton told Beach that he, Loggins, Patterson and Cannada went to the party together and were standing on the porch when Janie walked out of the house. As she passed them, he said, he heard a sound and turned and Janie was lying on the ground.


Patterson, one of the three proclaimed eyewitnesses to the fall, also was never put under oath, although she provided two conflicting statements to Beach in the presence of her parents. Patterson admits in her second statement that she had not been truthful about who had accompanied her to the party. Beach did not put Patterson in the re-enactment video.


Patterson said in her second statement that she went to the party with Loggins, Horton and Cannada. She said she was standing with her date, her arm through his, when Janie was coming from the garage. She added that, as she and her date were leaving in the dark, she looked back and saw Janie just sort of twist and fall. Patterson also stated that when she arrived at the party Janie called her a snob. Cannada was never put under oath for her statement to police. However, when interviewed by Beach, she said that she did not even attend the party. That proved to be the gist of her comment to authorities. Which was it? There or not? Sure leaves me wondering. There are at least eight other people who were at the party that day whom Ward said he already would have interviewed if he only had a prosecutor’s subpoena powers.


—––––– •–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.



__________________
Miz G


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2246
Date:

 Ms.G,


Thank you for the interesting information on Janie's case. I can't imagine losing my precious daughter in so henious a manner.


My prayers go out to Janie's family and friends. Very sad and tragic loss. 



__________________

....come death, and welcome! Juliet wills it so!



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

 annarocket - thank you for your concern and prayers for this family. They have suffered so much, for so long. Not only because of the loss of their precious Daughter, but having to fight  the "deep pockets" of the State of Arkansas. A Major "cover-up" began the night of Janie's brutal death, in a County of 7,841 people. It continued to Faulker County where the office of the Prosecuting Attorney [H.G. Foster] was based. Then on to [Little Rock] Pulaski County and the Arkansas Crime Lab. This story is almost like a fictional murder mystery. Unfortunately it is a True Story and this Family have been living it for 16 years, and 33 days.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Saturday, September 17, 2005


 
End of the rope


Ron and Mona Ward of Marshall,  whose 16-year-old daughter Janie died at a teen-age party outside that mountain community in 1989, say they are reaching the end of their rope financially and emotionally. "We have tried all we know to do," Ward said. "And we keep fighting to gain justice for our daughter. But we also are hurting in so many ways, including financially. The burdens on us are becoming crushing." Ward is a licensed bail bondsman in Searcy County. Lately, the court there hasn’t been giving him enough business to support a family. Since January, Ward has earned less than $2,000. The Wards placed their hopes in Special Prosecutor Tim Williamson of Mena, but they say that for weeks he has not responded to their inquiries about his supposed investigation into Janie’s death. Nor, they say, has he responded to their attorney’s questions about the case. He hasn’t responded to my questions, e-mailed to him over the past two months, either.


Meanwhile, the family’s expenses have continued to mount, including the thousands of dollars it has cost them to retain any voice whatsoever within the state’s legal system. I find myself wondering if this is how the Arkansas system of justice is supposed to operate for parents of slain children.


These parents of a girl who a boardcertified pathologist has determined was killed by blunt-force trauma to her head had to turn to a private lawyer for justice when the state refused for 16 years to act aggressively in determining the circumstances of Janie’s death. Makes me wonder how those responsible for this "justice" system would feel had this vibrant young girl been their child.


At any rate, valued readers, the Wards now have reached out through the national organization called Parents of Murdered Children in a desperate attempt to stay afloat in hopes of attracting the attention and support of John Gillis, who heads the U.S. Office of Victims of Crime in Washington.


Here, in part, is what Ward wrote in an appeal to Gillis that alleges a crime, a resulting cover-up and a sustained "wall of silence." "Mr. Gillis, we are asking for your help. We live here in Searcy County, Ark. Sixteen year ago this Sept. 9, our 16-year-old daughter, Olivia Jane Ward, was murdered at a school class party held deep in the backwoods at a rural cabin. Party-goers claim Janie fell backwards from a porch less than 10 inches high, killing her. This did not account for the broken nose and other trauma found on her face and body. For these many years we have pursued justice for her. The perpetrators... have been protected in a cover-up all these years....


" We have repeatedly asked the state for an investigation. Richard Walter of the Vidocq Society came to Arkansas twice in 2001 to assist in opening an investigation into Janie’s death. He found a wall of silence from officials and the state police. "With no help from the local DA or state officials, in October 2004 our attorney got an exhumation order signed by a circuit judge. Janie’s body was exhumed and given an autopsy by Dr. Harry Bonnell at the UAMS lab in Little Rock. Dr. Bonnell’s findings [were that] the cause of Janie’s death was blunt force trauma to her face. The manner: homicide.


" No state official chose to be present to witness Dr. Bonnell’s autopsy. His only witness, UAMS lab tech and assistant pathologist Kenny Parks, was murdered July 30, 2005. Arkansas state officials are opposing changing Janie’s death certificate to reflect Dr. Bonnell’s findings. "The special prosecutor that was appointed December 2004 to investigate Janie’s death has done nothing. To our knowledge, not a single witness has been questioned. He will not even return our phone calls or answer an e-mail to us." Mr. Gillis, we appeal to you to please contact the Justice Department in this matter. We find ourselves in a desperate situation here pursuing justice for our daughter. " If you’d like to help (or continue helping) the Ward family sustain their spirit and strength in the struggle to see justice done for Janie, account No. 93002194 was established in Janie Ward’s name at the First Team Bank, Box 398, Marshall AR 72650. If our justice system is so steadfastly resolute on failing this family, perhaps the many good people of Arkansas and their churches can express their feelings by helping the Wards to survive this shameful ordeal.


—–––––• –––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.


 



__________________
Miz G


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2246
Date:

It had been suggested in the past from one of our board members that Janie's family had been the victim of a corrupt system and that local officials involved had conspired to cover evidence in this case.


You know,it is bad enough that we have to hear stories of young people losing their lives but to hear that the family being victimized by an inept law enforcement system is twice as tragic.  



__________________

....come death, and welcome! Juliet wills it so!



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Very true annarocket. The corruption began in Searcy County, and moved on to the elected officials in Little Rock, the Capital of Arkansas. Unfortunately, it is still going on.


Janie Ward's Father, while standing by her Coffin, promised he would find who killed her, and have them brought to Justice. Can you imagine having your Child's body exhumed ? Having a second autopsy ? The Ward's did that. They had Dr. Harry Bonnell, a well known Board-Certified California Forensic Pathologist come to AR to do the second autopsy. They were refused use of the Crime Lab. Would not allow a Staff member to witness the autopsy.


The autopsy took place at the University of AR Medical School. Kenny Parks, an employee of that lab witnessed the autopsy. This past Summer, Kenny Parks was murdered, near his home.


Incidently, Dr. Bonnell did not charge for doing the autopsy. The Ward Family paid his travel expenses. They also paid for the exhumation. This was all at NO cost to the State of AR, and they would not cooperate !


Following is a great Editorial from the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette September 8, 2005


EDITORIALS :
Missing in action


IT’S BEEN more than eight months since a special prosecutor was named to look into the suspicious circumstances of a Marshall teenager’s death in 1989. Tim Williamson, the prosecutor from Mena, agreed to take on the difficult job. When he did, he pledged to get to the truth of what happened to Janie Ward. He even met with her long-suffering parents, held hands and prayed with them. Their prayer? That the truth of their daughter’s death would finally be revealed. Mr. Williamson told them he would investigate their daughter’s death as a homicide.


A lot of time has passed since Janie Ward’s death. There were many discrepancies in the original investigation. Evidence has been lost or mishandled. The original autopsy results seem ludicrously inaccurate. There’s a lot of misinformation out there that would need to be sorted out if the truth is to be found.


But eight months is plenty of time to make at least a dent in this mysterious case. But based on the silence that has descended over the prosecution of the case, there’s been little—if any—progress. Tim Williamson long ago stopped responding to Ron and Mona Ward. As a result, they’ve lost faith in the prosecutor.


Mike Masterson, our columnist who has written about so many of the discrepancies in the investigation of this case, is now also out of Mr. Williamson’s information loop. Columnist Masterson has been unable to determine if a single witness to Janie Ward’s death has been interviewed, or even contacted.


Hopes of getting the truth out have soured in the last eight months. This case has been strange from the beginning and now the investigation is as well. So far it’s produced mainly an uneasy silence. The most notable development, or nondevelopment, came a couple of months ago when Tim Williamson’s investigator in the case—Paul Bosson—wrote an angry letter to the editor, saying Mike Masterson didn’t know what he was talking about and, basically, should just sit down and shut up.


But all that outburst did was highlight the conflict of interest on the part of Mr. Bosson. He’s not only doing the investigation for Tim Willliamson, he’s also a member of the state Crime Laboratory Board. That’s the board that has opposed reclassifying Janie Ward’s death from undetermined to homicide. As a result, the crime lab is a defendant in a court petition filed by the Wards.


With the exception of his letter to the editor, Paul Bosson has been silent, too, especially in regard to his own conflict of interest in the case. The conflict is clear enough that the Wards want him removed from the investigation. But he’s staying on because—surprise—he says the Crime Lab board sees no conflict of interest. Yep, the same board whose actions, or non-actions, inspired the petition from the Wards.


Earlier this summer, Governor Mike Huckabee released $10,000 in state money to pay for the investigation into Janie Ward’s death. It’s now been two months since that announcement. It seems like a good time to begin asking for an accounting. Maybe the Guv can get some answers out of this special prosecutor—or at least get him to respond to his phone calls.


It’s not necessary to review again the many questionable details about the Janie Ward case. They’ve been reviewed in Mike Masterson’s columns and in occasional editorials month after month. Readers following the case are familiar with them already. And they continue to write letters to the editor. Not to complain about those who are asking questions, but to ask questions themselves: Why isn’t more being done to find out the truth about this case? And what in the world could possibly be taking so long?


The Janie Ward case has been a stain on the state of Arkansas from the start. There’s far too much evidence of bungling in high places, and the stain will not go away until an aggressive investigation gets to the truth of what happened to Janie Ward. The whole truth. But at the pace of the current investigation, Arkansas—and Janie Ward’s parents—will have to go on waiting for a long, long time. Like indefinitely. That would be intolerable.



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 23
Date:

" The autopsy took place at the University of AR Medical School. Kenny Parks, an employee of that lab witnessed the autopsy. This past Summer, Kenny Parks was murdered, near his home. "


  Wow MizG everything about this case wreaks of cover-up, but the above quote from your post literally spells it out. I feel so for her family and those who have tried to keep this in the light.




__________________
Granny


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

KansasGranny - You wrote - "Wow MizG everything about this case wreaks of cover-up, but the above quote from your post literally spells it out." That quote was - "The autopsy took place at the University of AR Medical School. Kenny Parks, an employee of that lab witnessed the autopsy. This past Summer, Kenny Parks was murdered, near his home." I totally agree, about the cover-up. It is deeper than anyone can imagine. Following is the article Mike Masterson wrote about Kenny Parks, it has additional details, that may be of interest to you.
August 7, 2005 Arkansas Democrat-Gazette


Ward witness murdered


Mike Masterson


The pathology technician and supervisor at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences who assisted Dr. Harry J. Bonnell last October during the California pathologist’s re-autopsy on the body of Marshall’s Janie Ward was murdered last Saturday outside a neighbor’s home. Police said Kenneth Morice Parks Sr., the sole medical witness to the postmortem by which Bonnell determined that 16-year-old Janie’s death in 1989 was a homicide from blunt-force trauma, was the victim of a mysterious crime last Saturday in which two black men invaded his neighbor’s Southwest Little Rock home, then shot him in the head after he and his wife responded to their young daughter’s call for help. Reportedly, earlier that evening the same gunmen had stopped by the house where Parks’ daughter would be playing pool later that night with six other kids ages 10 to 14 and asked who was in the house. Both men returned around 1:20 a.m. and burst through the door in a reported effort to rob the house. They rounded up all the kids, except for Parks’ 13-year-old daughter, who police said hid in a closet and called her parents from a cell phone. The 45-year-old Parks and his wife went next door from their home at 3 Sandhurst Circle and knocked on the neighbor’s door. One of the gunmen then shot him in the head as they fled with a small amount of money and jewelry. "This doesn’t make any sense," Sgt. Terry Hastings, a Little Rock police spokesman, said during the investigation later Saturday. No kidding, Sgt. Hastings. Talk about another bizarre development in the Ward case for our state’s criminal justice system. Man, oh, man, this one takes the cake.


Anyone else out there find Parks’ baffling murder as disturbing as I do? Anyone else reading this believe the odds of a home invasion and subsequent murder of a key witness in this case at this time are so remote as to be infinitesimal? I mean, how many residential murders at the hands of intruders (who first case that particular house) has our entire state had over the past decade?


Can I tell you without question that Ken Parks’ murder was related to his involvement with Bonnell and the Ward case? No, of course I can’t. A lot of loose ends would have to fit. But someone sure needs to be finding a truthful answer to that question when even Little Rock police are saying this crime makes no sense and they have no clues.


Bonnell told me that Parks was assigned by UAMS to assist him with routine autopsy matters in the Ward exhumation and second autopsy. "He handed me instruments and helped position her body," said Bonnell. But then, the forensic pathologist revealed something else to me about Parks that also seems relevant to the Ward case. "During the autopsy on Janie Ward, Mr. Parks told me he previously had worked with Dr. [Fahmy] Malak at the medical examiner’s office back when the physical conditions and resources there were especially bad," said Bonnell. "He didn’t mention if he had been connected in any way with her original autopsy, so I don’t know that." But Parks apparently had professional connections with Malak, whose initial autopsy on a potential murder victim was stunningly incomplete. But even Malak said Janie’s death needed "more investigation." If nothing else, Parks’ mysterious murder does underscore what I have been saying since last October. There is far more than has ever met the eye in this disgraceful case. The suspicious circumstances surrounding it cry out for a federal grand jury probe of everyone involved in either witnessing or investigating Janie’s death. Truth be known, the state has done nothing but "turtle up" in this case. And it needs a deep and thorough purging by a committed and impartial body led by a determined prosecutor who has no friends to favor or axes to grind. While we are pondering in unison over this, is anyone else also wondering what is up with Special Prosecutor Tim Williamson’s ongoing criminal "investigation" into this case, the investigation to which our governor has contributed $10,000 and which now is heading into its eighth month with not a single witness that I can find having been interviewed?


—––––– •–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.

           

-- Edited by Miz G at 21:45, 2005-10-13

-- Edited by Miz G at 02:23, 2005-10-14

__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette September 1, 2005

Prosecutor turtles up
Mike Masterson

Remember Tim Williamson?  I vaguely do. Isn’t he the 18 th Judicial District-West prosecutor from Mena who was appointed nine months ago to investigate and resolve the 1989 death of Marshall’s Olivia Jane Ward? But now there seems to be a problem. Thus far, neither the Ward family nor anyone else I’ve spoken with knows of one witness to Janie’s death having been interviewed by Williamson or the state police investigator reportedly working with him. In fact, the Wards have sent several e-mails over the months seeking updates on their daughter’s case without receiving any response from the special prosecutor. For them, it is as if he just vanished, poof! The scenario is familiar to this poor family. Much like the silence they have endured from the system over the years, they have once again lost hope after coming face-to-face with the familiar stone wall.


Even their attorney, Jerry Sallings of the Wright, Lindsey & Jennings firm in Little Rock, has yet to receive a reply to a letter of concerns and questions about the case that he sent to Williamson weeks ago. Sallings sent another e-mail earlier this week again seeking any response.


The last contact the Wards had from the prosecutor responsible for pursuing the investigation of their daughter’s death—a death that a nationally prominent forensic pathologist has called a homicide by blunt-force trauma—came on July 21 when Williamson sent the family an e-mail saying he was taking a badly needed week’s vacation and would get back to the case when he returned.


I haven’t heard from Williamson since the spring, so I e-mailed him on Monday to ask what has happened to his investigation, which launched with so much enthusiasm. I had received neither an acknowledgment or response by my deadline for this column.


My confusion over this stonewalling runs as deep as the Wards’ because, soon after his appointment, I was regularly receiving motivated e-mails from Williamson like the following two partial messages:


Jan. 17— "Mike: We have some momentum growing and I want to capitalize on it.... We will be busy this week. Thanks, Tim."


Feb. 7 —" I visited with Ron Ward by telephone at length this morning. I gave him a rather detailed report on what has been happening, in which something has been done daily since I met with Ron and Mona last month. Since it would normally be my usual practice of using the Arkansas State Police to be the primary investigative agency on matters such as this, we have had to make adjustments by adding new investigators due to the ASP issues involved. This case is 15 years old and I cannot get a resolution in 15 days. If anybody truly wants the truth to be known, I need time. I explained this to Ron. There is so much information and misinformation to be consumed and sorted. Thus, there is the need to collect additional information.... Take care, Tim. "


Well, by my calculations, it’s now been more than 270 days since Williamson got this case. He was obviously talking as though the case was moving forward back in early February, some five months before Gov. Mike Huckabee agreed to give $10,000 to help finance the investigation. Suppose the governor has heard how his emergency fund money has been spent? So, good people of Arkansas, I don’t know what to tell you except that it’s obvious that Williamson and his deputy, Paul Bosson of Hot Springs, have chosen to stop talking to anyone associated with the victim’s family. And that is mighty strange for a public servant who voluntarily accepted this position. Now I’m wondering, as are the Wards and many others across our state, just why he did.


—–––––•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Another touching article by Mike Masterson -


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette August 21, 2005


 
Roses and lights
 
Mike Masterson
 
Ron and Mona Ward of Marshall sat with hundreds of others in a darkened and somber hotel ballroom recently. Family members attending the annual Parents of Murdered Children convention each held a slender rose with a small light attached inside its petals. The Wards were seated at banquet tables at the Westin Crown Center Hotel in Kansas City, Mo., as part of a memorial service for so many relatives who have been murdered. As photographs with the dates of birth and death for each of the victims appeared individually on a giant screen and soft background music filled the room, their parents and other relatives identified themselves in the crowd by lighting their roses. This was the first time in the 16 years since their daughter Janie’s death that the Wards had ever attended a POMC conference, or even traveled very far outside of Searcy County. They had driven to Kansas City not knowing what to expect. What they found in the vast hotel and mall were other parents who understood their loss and dozens of experts on every aspect of dealing with the horror of a murdered child. These included psychologists, criminal investigators and even pathologists. They discovered an organization they wished they had known more about years ago after their 16-year-old daughter was brought back to Marshall, dead on arrival, from a junior class beer bust at a rural cabin. Any adult who knows the story of Olivia Jane Ward’s death also should know that the quickly accepted official version as related by three professed witnesses could not possibly have accounted for her hyperextended broken neck, broken nose, black eye, badly scuffed jeans, switched clothing, numerous facial bruises, and the bleeding down her neck and onto her shoulder.


As invited guests at the conference, where hundreds with similar heartbreaks had come for three days, the Wards finally found themselves among others who had plumbed the depths of sustained agony. They were the other mothers and fathers, as well as grandparents, who cared enough to listen to them. Like this simple Arkansas family, these people had paid the highest dues life can extract, the anguish that provided license to offer comment and advice.


Only these people could understand the pledge Ron Ward had made over Janie’s casket to seek and find justice for her death, a justice the state of Arkansas for so many years has failed to secure.


And after the father had spoken at the podium, these 500 or so people from every state stood in unison to applaud the family and their determined crusade.


Now here they were, all gathered around banquet tables in the darkened and packed room, watching the faces of their slain loved ones being projected into the room, lost lives dissolving and meshing one into another as the number of lighted roses swelled and the sounds of grief became audible. Mona Ward said the service was moving and perhaps somewhat cathartic for her and her husband. But it also was deeply painful for her, watching and understanding all the suffering that surrounded her in little lights. When you think about such horror, my friends, it does not, it cannot possibly get any more painful in this brief lifetime we share than to lose a beloved child to murder. And if that murder is never resolved, if it is left to linger year after year, and if those responsible for securing truth and justice in society fail miserably in their jobs, all of which has happened in Janie’s case, then that parental grief is only magnified. And so Mona watched and identified and listened to the soft background music in that enormous room filled with these images of the dead who seemingly yesterday were here. And when her daughter’s photograph appeared, she flipped on her light and stared into the smooth, smiling face of the child she had birthed and loved dearly. As did the others around her, she wept softly and wondered why their little girl had to depart so violently and senselessly. Then, after bidding yet another farewell to her daughter 15 years later, Mona and Ron rose and walked slowly out of the room. They had endured all that they could possibly bear for the moment.


—––––– •–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.



__________________
Miz G


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2246
Date:

Oh dear God. That last paragraph about the service that the Ward's attended made me feel like crying.


I can not imagine losing my beautiful daughter in such a heinious way and then to wind up not being able to recieve justice for those responsible for her death.


Please join me in praying for the Ward family to bring them the closure they deserve.  



__________________

....come death, and welcome! Juliet wills it so!



Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

My last post was Mike Masterson's "Roses and Lights."  That being the event Ron and Mona Ward attended in Kansas City, Missouri.
At that event, Ron accepted the award listed in the article below, on behalf of Mike Masterson.
Mike, a Staff Columnist  has been writing articles about the Janie Ward Case since he first learned about her case, late October 2004. He has read many of the documents that the Ward Family have shared with him, and has interviewed some of the people whose names were mentioned in those documents.
Mike has a column Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday and Sunday, in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette.
­­
­The following was published July 20th, 2005 in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette.
 
Group to give columnist service award.   The National Organization of Parents of Murdered Children Inc. will present Mike Masterson with its National Service Award at its national conference Aug. 13 in Kansas City, Mo.

    Masterson, a staff columnist for the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, has received more than 24 journalism honors, including being a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in both national and specialized reporting. He was written more than 40 columns since October revealing new facts and calling local and state criminal justice authorities to account for the unresolved 1989 death of 16 year-old Janie Ward of Marshall.

    Parents of Murdered Children Inc. was founded by Robert and Charlotte Hullinger in Cincinnati after the murder of their 19-year-old daughter, Lisa, by a former boyfriend. The organization assists more than 100,000 surviving family members and loved ones of homicide victims.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Yes, annarocket, most people that have read the "Roses and Lights" article do have tears. It is difficult to understand how a Mother and Father would feel, seeing their beloved Daughter on a big screen. Knowing that at the age of 16, she was needlessly, brutally killed. That the persons that were responsible, are living their lives as they see fit.
I only hope they have nightmares. That they see the lifeless body of Olivia Jane Ward on the back of that pick-up truck.
I pray for the Family and for Justice, every day.



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Another voice for Janie
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette June 21, 2005 Written by Mike Masterson
 

There are some Arkansas journalists expressing thoughts about the Olivia Jane Ward case other than those you’ve been reading for months on this page. Reporter Kevan Mathis of the Harrison Daily Times, who last fall called my attention to the travesties in the Marshall teen-ager’s 1989 death, has steadily reported news of the case and recently published his opinion of it in my hometown paper. Following is some of what Mathis wrote on June 12 under the headline, "Marshall family needs healing," just days before Gov. Mike Huckabee pulled $10,000 from his emergency fund to assist an ongoing investigation by Special Prosecutor Tim Williamson of Mena. "It’s time the right people at the state level step up to the plate and do the right thing.... The state doesn’t need to exhume Janie’s body again. The family, at their own expense and accompanied by Searcy County deputies and Arkansas State Police, exhumed Janie’s body October 8, 2004. I know because I was there.


" And a totally independent examination of her body was accomplished by noted pathologist Dr. Harry Bonnell of San Diego at no charge. How much more of an independent autopsy can you get? "... Ron and Mona Ward of Marshall believe their 16-year-old daughter was murdered on Sept. 9, 1989, near a cabin at Zack Ridge in Searcy County while attending a party with several classmates. A few witnesses said Janie died after she fell off a 9-inch-high porch.


" Bonnell’s autopsy report documented that Janie had suffered a broken nose, a black eye, and other facial, neck and shoulder bleeding and abrasions. His report concludes her death was ‘a homicide’ caused by blunt force trauma to the front of the head. She had a hyperextension injury (her head was knocked too far backwards) with fracture of the spine in the neck. This injury is sometimes referred to as a ‘hangman’s’ fracture. There was no evidence of any impact to the back of the head, although the original autopsy report describes one, Bonnell wrote. "Bonnell stated the presence of ‘dirt and muck’ on her clothes as well as paramedic statements that [the fact that] she had sand beneath her wet clothing indicates she had been in a river or lake.


" Bonnell’s findings also state he was most disturbed by one of the X-ray films originally relied upon by former Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Fahmy Malak in his 1989 autopsy of Janie that appears to be the skull of a black male, not that of a white female. ‘Missing evidence, changed clothing and multiple other discrepancies dictate that this death investigation must be re-opened and done properly,’ wrote Bonnell. "Dr. Bonnell concluded Janie’s injuries indicate not a fall, but an assault. Some of his findings were supported by the official report of two paramedics—J. D. Beason and Velma Catherine Beason—who responded to the original emergency call on the night Janie died.


" In 1992, the state retained two pathologists—Dr. Michael Graham and Dr. Marc Krouse—to re-examine Dr. Malak’s autopsy results. Both doctors disagreed with Malak’s findings and said a new investigation was needed. Dr. Graham stated that it would be ‘very unusual’ for a person to die from falling 9 inches off a porch. He was particularly troubled by the ‘wetness of her clothing, alterations in what Janie was wearing and the presence of sand and other materials in her clothing and on her body.’ Dr. Krouse also said Janie could not have died from any of the reported injuries by falling off a porch. ‘There is even the possibility of a drowning and subsequent cover-up, and the case requires further investigation,’ Krouse wrote in a court petition. "It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out there are too many issues in this case that don’t add up. And it doesn’t take a genius to figure out it’s time for state officials to accept their responsibilities to the grieving Ward family, impanel a grand jury from a different judicial district and appoint independent investigators to do what should’ve been done 15 years ago.


" Another exhumation is not warranted in this case. What’s needed are new, independent investigators to reinterview all the people at the party that fateful night in Marshall. Someone knows what really happened and someone will talk. "It seems like state officials aren’t as interested in getting their own independent examination or investigation as they are in getting experts to tell them what they want to hear."


Right to the point, Kevan.


In related notes: The Wards and their attorneys with the Wright, Lindsey & Jennings firm in Little Rock are insisting that Bonnell be prominently included in any plans for a second exhumation and third autopsy on their daughter’s remains. You and I would insist on his presence, too, had Janie been our daughter. Also, more than 100 readers from across Arkansas have contributed a total of $7,000 to assist the Ward family in settling its extensive debts resulting from Janie’s exhumation last fall. Others can still help them by sending a check in any amount to the Janie Ward Fund, First Team Bank, P. O. Box 398, Marshall AR 72650.


—––––– •–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette April 9, 2005    Mike Masterson writes - "Arkansas Cold Shoulder"   A member of a national society that investigates cold crime cases got a massive cold shoulder when he visited Arkansas three years ago to help solve the homicide of Olivia Jane Ward. It quickly became clear to Richard Walter of the Philadelphia-based Vidocq Society that no official responsible for investigating Janie’s death wanted him snooping around the teetering shack of missing evidence and unresolved questions they had carefully built on shifting sand. "I found them to be closed," Walter told me. "They had made up their minds what it (Janie’s death) was. I was not exactly welcomed with open arms—not that I required that. I found an unwillingness by others to even address the facts, much less consider them." After examining all that he could during visits in the fall of 2001 and the spring of 2002, Walter said Janie’s brutal death clearly "smelled, looked and acted like a homicide." Then, of course, it became a matter of who would dispute the official version. Certainly not local sheriff Kent Griggs, or the primary Arkansas State Police investigator, Bill Beach, or 20 th District Prosecutor H. G. Foster, all of whom left the circumstances of Janie’s death dangling as "undetermined" for 15 years.

In fact, no state or federal authority has yet displayed the will to resolve Janie’s case because of who was involved in her death and the grimy politics that sidetracked any genuine investigation from the first hours. For the Ward family of Marshall, this gross miscarriage has represented our state’s "criminal injustice system." "When you read the real facts as reported," said Walter, "there are issues in the statements and reports that don’t add up to anything other than homicide." To him, Janie’s case also involves the "treacherousness of stupidity compounded by people... who want to shut it down."


Walter believes that it’s always been possible to resolve Janie’s homicide, "but first you have to have the will to solve it. Officials probably have the ability, but the will was missing." He said he would return to assist only if he’s invited and after "all the politics" are removed.


During both of his visits, he said, he believed that local officials and others within the Arkansas State Police and state Crime Laboratory were eager to buy the preposterous contention that Janie died after falling off a porch step less than 10 inches high. "People become invested in opinions," he said. "I’m not sure this started out to be a cabal of cover-up, but sometimes, like a tumbleweed, it can just grow."


He made his trips to Arkansas largely at the Pennsylvania society’s expense. This same group has been invited and welcomed into stalled investigations in many states over the years. It is named after Eugene François Vidocq, a renown 18 th century French convict turned exemplary police investigator after whom Victor Hugo fashioned two characters in his novel, "Les Miserables."


Its volunteer members, who meet monthly over dinner to vote on and review cases in a historic Philadelphia hall, are highly regarded experts in various aspects of researching unsolved crimes. The non-profit society has helped solve numerous murders with local authorities who seek their assistance. The Vidocq Society voted to become involved in Janie’s case after the Ward family, supported by the National Organization of Parents of Murdered Children, requested the group’s assistance in 2001.


Walter specializes in crime scene analysis and assessment. He said he found himself angrily confronted by a pathologist from the Arkansas medical examiner’s office when he raised Janie’s death in casual conversation at a conference several years ago.


Apparently, the argumentative pathologist was forcefully defending our state’s official version of Janie’s death from a porch stumble (or perhaps from an irregular heartbeat, as the state’s current chief medical examiner, Dr. Charles Kokes, has suggested). Walter said of that unexpectedly rude confrontation: "Denial is not a river in Egypt."


Walter’s visits came two years before Dr. Harry J. Bonnell of San Diego exhumed Janie’s body and performed his own autopsy. Bonnell found precisely the same injuries that several eyewitnesses described at the scene. He also took X-rays of the girl’s fractured neck (not described in her original autopsy) and concluded that her death was a homicide from blunt-force trauma. Today, the investigation and resolution of the disgraceful case rests solely with 18 th Judicial District Prosecutor Tim Williamson of Mena and his deputy, Paul Bosson of Hot Springs, a retired prosecutor who’s also on the state Crime Lab board. The Ward family and many others across the state have placed their faith in Williamson to bring this chronic infection to a head. Will he? Williamson and Bosson surely would never remotely consider succumbing to the same political derailing maneuvers that have plagued this case. Surely they will find the courage to finally do the right thing by Janie Ward. I know our state is patiently watching, as are Walter and his society.


—–––––•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.



-- Edited by Miz G at 00:51, 2005-10-24

__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:


Ron Ward Father of Janie Ward was interviewed Tuesday October 25, 2005, on the Pat Lynch Show from Little Rock, Arkansas. Anyone, anywhere will be able to listen to this heart rendering story of a Father speaking on the tragic and brutal death of he and his Wife Mona's precious Daughter Janie September 9, 1989.
 
http://www.wairadio.com/
 
When the link is open, go to Archives on the left side of the page.
Click on Archives. It will take you to Pat Classic - Scroll down to the date
10-25-05-10AM - RON WARD FATHER OF JANIE WARD TELLS THE STORY OF HIS DAUGHTERS DEATH AND THE SUSPECTED COVER-UP.
JANIE WAS KILLED IN 1989.
If you move your cursor over those words, they will disappear and the broadcast will open, on Windows Media Player.
It takes awhile to download, but is well worth the wait.
Don't forget to pray for this Family and for Justice finally to be served for Olivia Jane Ward.
That would enable the Ward Family to finally find closure, and get on with their lives.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
On that same website, if you will go to 10-17-05-10AM - you will be able to hear Pat Lynch interview Mike Masterson. They spoke about a lot of things, and during the last half hour, they discussed the Janie Ward Case.
 
 
 



__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

The following letter published today, was in response to one published October 8, 2005, see both letters below.
 
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Thursday October 27, 2005 Letter to the Editor
 
Case must be resolved
   M. Jack Hitt’s letter to the editor was great. He wrote that Gov. Mike Huckabee must step in [to the investigation of the death of Janie Ward], that "he cares greatly about justice for Janie Ward" and "is the only one who can bring this burlesque to a conclusion," that "if he does not take this ‘investigation’ in hand and see that it is truthfully resolved, then he will be . . . equally responsible."
   I wrote a six-page letter to Huckabee; went into great details and asked for his help and sent along a column Mike Masterson wrote on Nov. 24, 2004. Masterson [said he wrote it while] looking at a color picture of Janie taken inside the state Crime Lab the day after her violent death. He wrote in graphic detail about it.
   Recently, the governor’s policy adviser replied to me, "The Governor is prohibited from interfering with the affairs of the other branches of government. . . . [He] cannot interfere with a judge and/or prosecuting attorney in the performance of their duties."
   I disagree that he cannot help, and after reading that response, I now agree with Hitt: He is equally responsible.
   ARLENE G. BRIGHTBILL
   Leslie

 
 
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette October 8, 2005 Letter to the Editor
 
Huckabee must step in
   It’s a good thing that vengeance and justice is the Lord’s, because there is precious little of it here on Earth.
   I don’t know whether I would spend as much of my life, emotions and finances over a 15-year period as the Wards have done, but I feel their agony over the non-resolution of their daughter’s death. Everything that’s been done on the case since her death, if not by murder then certainly by foul play, has been a travesty.
   Finally, after years of perseverance, a champion of the Wards appeared, Mike Masterson. His passion pushed authorities into appointing a special prosecutor, Tim Williamson, to look into this case. Williamson promised a thorough investigation and resolution, but nothing has happened. . . . Whatever the reason, Williamson is totally ineffective and his "investigation" is a joke.
   Gov. Mike Huckabee must step in. I attend church with him and often greet him as he enters, and I would never intrude into his preparation for worship. However, I want to intrude now and tell him that if he does not take this "investigation" in hand and see that it is truthfully resolved, then he will be . . . equally responsible.
   I know he is very compassionate and that he cares greatly about justice for Janie Ward and her parents. He is the only one who can bring this burlesque to a conclusion.
   M. JACK HITT
   Little Rock





__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Mike Masterson writes on Janie Ward Case November 1, 2005


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette  Tuesday November 1, 2005


Ironic witness
 
Mike Masterson

   "Every person is entitled to a certain remedy in the laws for all injuries or wrongs he may receive in his person, property or character; he ought to be able to obtain justice freely, and without purchase; completely and without denial; promptly and without delay; comformably to the laws."—Arkansas Constitution, Article II, Section 13.
   Dr. Marc Krouse didn’t hold any punches back in early July 1992 after reviewing the state medical examiner’s incomplete file on the 9-inch backward fall from a cabin porch that three witnesses ludicrously claimed killed Marshall’s Janie Ward.
   "I think it’s bulls---," the pathologist told the deceased girl’s father in a taperecorded meeting. "I don’t see anything to go with it. Absolutely nothing."
   What makes this significant is that Krouse, then the Tarrant County (Texas) deputy chief medical examiner, along with Dr. Michael Graham of St. Louis, is listed as an expert witness for the state in its ongoing attempt to prevent Ron and Mona Ward from having their daughter’s death certificate officially revised from "undetermined" to "homicide."
   The manner of a person’s death can be legally listed on a death certificate either as accidental, homicide, natural or undetermined. The cause of death means the physical act that caused a person to die as determined by a coroner or medical examiner.
   Perhaps ironically, it was Drs. Krouse and Graham whose review of the 1989 autopsy performed by Dr. Fahmy Malak, then the state’s chief medical examiner, that led to a court-ordered change of the cause of the 16-year-old’s violent death from "upper spinal cord and neck injury" to "undetermined."
   This was based solely on Krouse and Graham’s 1992 review of the paperwork of Malak’s findings, which in itself was incomplete. Even at that, their rebuttal of Malak’s action, subsequently approved by the court, bore only Malak’s name, which was typed, but unsigned. That left me, and, I suspect, others, believing that this change had been Malak’s decision.
   The two pathologists decided to recommend changing the manner of death cited by Malak from "undetermined" because nothing of Janie’s neck could even be seen in an X-ray photo because the area was cloaked by a white mass. This photo was a far different version from the actual, original X-ray image the Wards say they were shown at the state Crime Lab in 1989. They say that one clearly showed Janie’s fractured neck.
   Both doctors said the photographed version of the X-ray, which did not bear the original medical examiner’s evidence ID tag, normally burned into the lower right corner, appeared to them to depict a black male rather than Janie Ward.
   Ron Ward said that when he called former state Crime Lab director Jim Clark to ask about the cloaked X-ray, Clark told him he had given the family "what was in the file." Ward said Clark later told him that the original X-rays had to be destroyed for lack of storage space.
   After Krouse told Ward that he believed the backward fall from a porch version was "bulls---," Ward asked if that meant that his daughter’s case, after two years, was back at "square one."
   "Yeah, that’s right," Krouse can be heard to respond on tape.
   The taped conversation continues:
   Ward: "So the story of her fall off the porch like you said is big old bull?"
   Krouse: "I don’t see anything in here to support that. I don’t see anything in there that makes any sense to me."
   An unequivocal, straightforward, intensely accurate conclusion if I’ve ever heard one.
   Krouse then is heard reading the full report submitted to the Arkansas Crime Laboratory Board. Among other aspects of the case, Krouse says he cannot rule out drowning, and he elaborates on it as a possible cause of death, given statements in the case file and the wet, sandy condition of Janie’s body and clothes as described by witnesses, who included paramedics.
   Dr. Lee Beamer, another pathologist who reviewed this shamefully handled case, noted that the weight of Janie’s lungs was almost twice the normal body weight for those organs, indicating that they were filled with fluid. This point wasn’t noted on Malak’s autopsy.
   Ward finished his discussion with Krouse by asking if his daughter’s case demanded further investigation.
   "I think it requires it," Krouse replied.
   Twelve long years later, in October 2004, Dr. Harry Bonnell, a nationally regarded, board-certified forensic pathologist from San Diego, fulfilled that requirement by performing a second autopsy following the exhumation of Janie’s well-preserved remains.
   Bonnell found and clearly X-rayed the same hyperextended, fractured neck that the Wards had originally seen, as well as a black eye, a broken nose, and other neck and facial injuries that he said made her death a "homicide."
   And still, our state—ironically, using Dr. Mark Krouse—fights against embracing Bonnell’s findings.
   —–––––
•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers




__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

Letter to the Editor Re: Olivia Jane Ward Case
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette  Sunday November 6, 2005
 
 Situation unacceptable
   Re Jack Mayberry’s challenge to support Janie Ward’s parents in their quest for justice related to her death: I have been following this case from its inception and am appalled that our justice system has failed so miserably. It is an embarrassment to the state as well as its complacent citizens.
   This is not my first letter regarding what appears to be a cover-up. I have previously written to the special prosecutor as well as the governor urging action, preferably a grand jury investigation, but received no response.
   I can see no acceptable excuse for the lack of investigation in this young teen’s death. One is left to assume that someone has something to hide.
   DELIA JAMES
   Hope


__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette  Monday November 7, 2005
Letter to the Editor Re: Janie Ward Case
 
Wait for justice goes on
   Anyone who has read about Janie Ward’s death surely knows that, at best, the investigation was mishandled by inept local authorities. They also would probably question how a fall from a porch less than a foot off the ground and onto dirt killed a healthy teen-ager.
   Additionally, an informed citizen might also realize that at the time of her death, the reliability of autopsy results performed by Fahmy Malek, then state medical examiner, had been questioned by numerous authorities.
   One would think that would be sufficient reason for the state’s criminal justice system to act upon this bereaved family’s persistent request for further investigation, and now, after 16 frustrating years, a special grand jury investigation.
   Shamefully, they are still waiting and begging for help from our state’s criminal justice system.
   Is this how Arkansans want to be perceived? Is justice only for the wealthy or politically powerful in this state?
STAN JAMES Hope


__________________
Miz G


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:


Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Saturday November 12, 2005
 

ABCs of Janie Ward


Mike Masterson 
   Ron and Mona Ward of Marshall were slated to meet Wednesday afternoon in Little Rock with their attorney, Jerry Sallings, and an Emmy Award-winning ABC-TV producer, Teri Whitcraft.
   The parents of Janie Ward, a 16-yearold who supposedly broke her neck and died after falling 9 /2 inches off a porch in September 1989, were set to show exactly why they believe crucial evidence in her death was tampered with inside the state Crime Laboratory 16 years ago.
   After performing a new autopsy last year, a California forensic pathologist determined that Janie’s death was a homicide caused by trauma to the head and face.
   The ABC Justice Unit out of New York began examining Janie’s death last summer when Whitcraft was in Arkansas. Its investigation continues, and a documentary is planned for eventual airing on an ABC national news program.
   That’s very good for the Wards and the many good people across Arkansas who have diligently followed this case for the 13 months I’ve been writing about it, and probably very bad news for anyone who might have been involved in obscuring the truth in this sad and disgraceful case for 16 long years. Stay tuned.
 
•–––––—Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former
editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.




__________________
Miz G


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 5
Date:

MIZ G HELLO AND HOW ARE YOU? FIRST OF ALL THANKS FOR THE INTERSESTING UPKEEPS ON THIS STORY I HAVE READ ALL THAT I CAN AND HEARD OF IT FROM JUSTICE JUNCTION, I PRAY FOR THE WARD'S AND ALWAYS HOPE THAT ONE DAY THEY WILL FIND CLOSURE!!! I WILL WAIT TO HEAR FROM YOU MORE ABOUT THIS CASE!! UNTIL THEN GOD BLESS!!!!!

__________________
JACQUELINE MITCHELL


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:


Mike Masterson on Janie Ward ! !
 
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Tuesday November 15, 2005
 
Exercise in futility

Mike Masterson

    Tim Williamson of Mena, the special prosecutor assigned by 20th  Judicial District Judge Charles Clawson of Conway to investigate the 1989 death of Marshall’s Janie Ward, continues to frustrate the victim’s family.

    Ron Ward, the father of the girl who supposedly fell about 9 inches off a cabin porch, breaking her nose, blackening her eye and fracturing her neck, said he has sent dozens of e-mails to Williamson since July without response.

    Williamson, the 18th Judicial District prosecutor, broke off contact with me about the same time after a flurry of enthusiastic e-mails and calls between us last winter after he was assigned to the case.

    The Wards said they have yet to hear of anyone in or around Marshall who was a witness or an attendee at the party where Janie died being formally interviewed or questioned.

    Even the Wards’ private attorney, Jerry Sallings of the Wright, Lindsey & Jennings law firm in Little Rock, has been unable to tweak any response out of Williamson despite numerous calls and letters seeking basic details about his investigation.

    Think I’m exaggerating? Here is what Sallings wrote to Williamson on Nov. 1:     “Dear Tim: As you know, I represent the Ward family in their quest for a full and complete investigation into the death of their daughter, Janie Ward. Although somewhat apprehensive at the beginning, the Wards were excited and encouraged after meeting with you about this case.

    “I, too, was excited and confident after receiving favorable reports from other lawyers in your community. We are trying hard to remain confident and encouraged. However, it is difficult when we receive no reports or even responses to requests for updates from your office.

    “I acknowledge that there likely would be sensitive, confidential information that you would not want, or need, to relay in that it could compromise the investigation. The Wards understand this and would not ask you to compromise this concern.

    “In fact, the Wards are primarily interested in obtaining a complete, thorough and untainted investigation of the death of their daughter. They are interested in learning what efforts have been made, what ideas you have to further the investigation and a very general update of how things are going.

    “While there may not be any specific legal requirement that you communicate with the Wards, certainly the spirit of [the Arkansas statute cited here] strongly suggests that you keep the family informed. Moreover, as was discussed in your initial meeting with the Wards, they have access to information that could be helpful to your investigation.

    “Finally, the Wards do not want to alienate you; rather, they are very anxious to do everything in their power to assist you. They have patiently, persistently and doggedly pursued this matter for 16 years. They have placed great trust and hope in you to seek out and find answers. Your office has been armed with $10,000 [from the governor’s emergency fund] to investigate this case. Please let us hear from you at your earliest convenience.”     Two weeks have passed since Sallings mailed this letter and, as of my deadline for this column on Monday, there still has been not a peep out of the special prosecutor to him or the Ward family.

    Did I mention that Williamson was appointed by Circuit Judge Charles Clawson? Oh, yeah, I remember now, I did.

    If you’d like to add your opinion as a concerned Arkansan, Williamson can be reached at P.O. Drawer 109, Mena AR 71953, or e-mail him at prosecutor18west@aol.com. But I should caution you not to hold off on showers or mortgage payments in anticipation of a response.

    Because I have written about this case in many, many columns spanning more than a year now, some of you have wondered how long I will continue to write about it. My response is that I will write about Janie Ward’s violent death and the dark stain it has left on our state’s criminal justice system until that sacred system effectively, honestly and thoroughly deals with it in an honorable manner.

    After all, my friends, this is the very system we fund to provide us all with equal justice regardless of where we might reside in the pecking order. In a shameful case like this, which I believe anyone with a sixth-grade education can quickly see is filled with falsehoods, deception, manipulation and favoritism, that justice continues to be much too long denied.

    —–––––
•–––––—    Staff columnist Mike Masterson is the former editor of three Arkansas daily newspapers.







__________________
Miz G
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard